Targeting 'addiction switch' may help combat alcohol addiction
"Alcoholics are missing 'vital chemical in their brain' that helps control addiction," the Daily Express reports.
Research carried out on rats suggests that low levels of the PRDM2 enzyme could trigger self-destructive addictive behaviour associated with alcohol dependency; leading people to continue to drink even though it is causing them physical and mental stress.
The studies showed that levels of this enzyme were lower in brain cells of the frontal lobe in rats that had previously been made dependent on alcohol, through being made to inhale alcohol vapour. These rats showed signs of addiction such as increased drinking of alcohol, even when it was mixed with bitter quinine, and seeking alcohol when stressed by being given electric shocks.
The researchers then found that rats which had not been exposed to alcohol vapour showed similar behaviour, after being treated to prevent them from producing PRDM2. They say this shows that the enzyme is important in controlling impulsive behaviour, which is difficult for people with alcohol addiction.
The obvious caveats about extrapolating animal research to humans apply.
The lead researcher said he hoped the findings would lead to medicines that can help people recover from alcohol addiction.
Current treatment options for alcohol dependency include talking therapies, group therapy, and medication that can help relieve cravings and prevent relapses.
To keep your risk of alcohol-related harm low, the NHS recommends not regularly drinking more than 14 units of alcohol a week.
If you are worried about your alcohol consumption, speak to your GP to find out more about treatment options.
What are enzymes?
Enzymes are molecules, usually proteins, that are involved in accelerating chemical reactions inside the body. For example, enzymes play a vital role in helping the body digest food.
Where did the story come from?
The study was carried out by researchers from Linköping University in Sweden, University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, and the University of Georgia, all in the US. It was funded by the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, the Swedish Research Council and United States Department of Defense.
The Times says that cancer drugs "could help alcoholics give up drink." This claim seems to be based on interviews with researchers, rather than anything in the study, which did not look at any medicines that might reverse the effects of the enzyme found to be lower in alcohol-dependent rats. The headline could raise hopes that a treatment for alcohol addiction is closer than it actually is.
The Daily Express fails to make it clear in its report that there is no direct evidence from this study that lack of PRDM2 is responsible for alcohol addiction in humans. This may be because the researchers' press release was headed: "People with alcohol dependency lack important enzyme," and doesn't mention animal research until the seventh paragraph.
What kind of research was this?
This was a series of animal experiments on rats in a laboratory, including manipulation of genes responsible for producing the enzyme PRDM2. These types of studies are helpful to understand molecular pathways behind diseases like alcohol addiction, but they do not investigate cures. Also, findings that apply to animals do not always translate to humans.
What did the research involve?
Researchers did a series of experiments involving rats that had been exposed to breathing alcohol vapour for 14 hours a day over seven weeks. This makes them "dependent" on alcohol. The researchers studied their behaviour in a series of behavioural experiments, including seeing whether they continued to drink alcohol when it was mixed with bitter-tasting quinine.
The researchers examined brain tissue cells for production of enzymes including PRDM2 and carried out DNA sequencing to examine the function of nerve cells affected by these enzymes. They used DNA analysis and cell chemistry techniques to look at expression of PRDM2 and behavioural experiments to examine the effects of changing this enzyme expression. They then carried out behavioural experiments on rats that had not been exposed to alcohol vapour, but which had been genetically manipulated not to produce PRDM2.
The behaviour of these rats was compared to rats with normal PRDM2 expression.
The researchers wanted to understand the role of different enzymes, and whether specific enzymes could be identified that affected alcohol addiction or produced behaviour similar to that shown by rats dependent on alcohol.
What were the basic results?
Researchers found that rats with alcohol dependency, as shown by their behaviour, had lower levels of the enzyme PRDM2 produced in their prefrontal cortex cells, weeks after they had stopped receiving alcohol.
In the second series of experiments, rats engineered not to produce PRDM2 showed similar behavioural signs of alcohol dependency, despite not having been exposed to alcohol vapour. Compared to rats with normal PRDM2 production, they were likely to drink more alcohol, to drink compulsively despite the bitter quinine taste, and to drink alcohol in response to electric shock stress. They were no more likely than normal rats to drink more sugar solution, suggesting that the effects of PRDM2 were specific to alcohol.
How did the researchers interpret the results?
In their paper, the researchers said "these observations suggest that long-term repression of PRDM2 is a key epigenetic mechanism contributing to a cluster of behaviours thought to be at the core of alcohol addiction." Epigenetics is the way in which genes are switched on and off, in response to external stimuli including enzymes.
They concluded that this gave a "strong rationale to explore PRDM2 or some of its downstream targets as candidate targets for novel alcoholism medications." They say that reversing the changes seen in alcohol addiction where the cells stop producing PRDM2 might "promote a transition back to a preaddicted state."
It seems likely that many factors influence why some people become addicted to alcohol and not simply a single enzyme. This new study shows that a change in enzyme production by brain cells of rats who have been forcibly exposed to alcohol vapour may be part of the process by which animals become dependent on alcohol. But despite the claims in the press release, this study does not prove anything about human brain cells, enzymes or alcohol addiction.
One researcher expressed the hope that his findings would "do away with the stigmatisation of alcoholism," by showing that it has a biochemical basis. While this is a laudable aim, the research published today does not show that the same mechanisms operational in rat brains operate in human brains. We do not know whether PRDM2 expression is the key to developing alcohol addiction for humans, even if animal research suggests it may be.
The findings open up possibilities for future research in humans, and may even one day lead to new drugs to reverse people's dependency on alcohol. That is still a way off, however, and much more research needs to be done before new drugs are likely to be available.
If you are worried you may have a problem with alcohol, talk to your GP or find out more about getting help with our information on alcohol support.
"Alcoholics are missing 'vital chemical in their brain' that helps control addiction," the Daily Express reports. Research carried out on rats suggests that low levels of the PRDM2 enzyme could trigger self-destructive addictive behaviour.
Links to Headlines
Alcoholics are missing 'vital chemical in their brain' that helps control addiction. Daily Express, August 31 2016
Cancer drugs could help alcoholics to give up drink. The Times, August 31 2016 (subscription required)
Alcoholics lack a key enzyme in the brain - and this creates a 'vicious cycle' of addiction. Wired, August 30 2016
Links to Science
Barbier E, Johnstone AL, Khomtchouk BB, et al. Dependence-induced increase of alcohol self-administration and compulsive drinking mediated by the histone methyltransferase PRDM2. Molecular Psychiatry. Published online August 30 2016
- Nutrient drink for Alzheimer's has disappointing result in trial
- Marriage may help lower dementia risk
- Blood-thinning drugs may reduce dementia risk in people with irregular heartbeats
- 'Magic mushrooms' may help 'reset' depressive brains, study claims
- NHS Choices links
- Alcohol support
- Tips on cutting down
- 'Going dry for a month boosted my health'
- Editor's pick of the blogs
- Evidently Cochrane
- Fact Check Central
- Research the Headlines
- Science-Based Medicine
- Science blog - Cancer Research UK
- Science Media Centre
- Sense about Science
- Understanding Health Research